Suppose you’ve come into some extra cash. You decide to use it prudently in one of three ways: keeping it in cash, putting it into your retirement plan, or paying off your mortgage. Which is the better option?
I usually find the answer isn’t just about the money. Paul Thorstenson, an accountant with Ketel Thorstenson, agrees. He calls paying off a home loan “as much a personal decision as an investment one.”
The first factor to consider is investment return. Thorstenson suggests you think of paying off debt as a risk-free investment. “Because the interest is fully deductible if you itemize, your paydown of the debt is exactly equivalent to making a risk-free investment (like a CD) that pays you a taxable yield equivalent to your interest rate.”
If your interest rate is 4.5%, that’s the return you will earn on the money you invest in paying off your mortgage. If this is difficult to visualize, think of it this way. When you pay off your debt, you are actually buying your loan from your bank much like banks sell loans to one another. You continue to make payments, only now the payments go to you instead of the bank. The money you invested in “buying” (paying off) the mortgage is now earning 4.5% for you instead of your bank.
Paying down (investing) your own debt is usually much better than keeping your funds in a money market, savings account, or certificate of deposit where they earn .5% to 2%.
A trickier decision is whether to invest the funds rather than pay debt. While investing always carries some risk, a diversified portfolio with 60% stocks and alternative investments (real estate, commodities, managed futures) and 40% bonds will typically return 6% to 8% over ten or more years.
If you can use your extra cash to maximize a contribution to a retirement account like an IRA or 401(k), you will earn 6% to 8% tax deferred (or tax free with a Roth IRA) which is better than paying off a debt yielding 4.5%. The younger you are, the more sense it makes to contribute the funds to a retirement account.
If the investments are not in a retirement account, then you must compare the after-tax return to get an equivalent comparison. For example, if you are in a 25% tax bracket and will earn 6% on your investment, your after-tax return is 4.5%, exactly equal to what you would earn in our example of paying down the debt. In this case, I would usually take the “guaranteed” investment of paying down the debt.
In deciding whether to pay off a home mortgage, there are some additional tax and emotional considerations.
Thorstenson notes that there are currently no limitations on the deductibility of loan interest, even by high income taxpayers. The “phaseouts” which expired two years ago will come back again in 2013 when (and if) the Bush tax cuts expire. “With the phaseout you will lose 3% of every dollar of deduction for every dollar of income that exceeds about $150,000.” For most taxpayers, this won’t be a major factor.
Probably more important than the investment and tax considerations are the emotional benefits of paying off home mortgage debt. Thorstenson says, “It gives one a sense of freedom in that you are not handcuffed to a mortgage. I’ve never once seen a client who had a paid-off house go leverage it back up and buy a mutual fund. Paying off a home is a great emotional accomplishment.”
That sense of accomplishment may be the most important investment return you can have.
Rick Kahler is a Certified Financial Planner™ professional licensed with a registered investment adviser that provides personal financial advice online for a flat fee.He is an author of four books on financial psychology and recognized by BusinessWeek magazine as one of the 15 most experienced financial planners in the nation. Contact Rick for help on virtually any financial need.